Lapsed Donor Reactivation

Retain More Donors with Tested Engagement Approaches

Re-engage lapsed donors using smart segmentation and tailored messaging.

White arrow pointing diagonally up and to the right on a black background.
Three-panel dashboard showing email campaigns to different audiences, a segmented list of donors, and donation insights with total $12,890 and breakdown of one-time and recurring donations.
KEY FUNCTIONALITIES

Turn Donor Retention into Your Superpower

Personalize Your Communications

Tailor messages to donor interests and profile, making every supporter feel valued.

Diagram showing DonorSpring sending emails to three audiences labeled Audience A, Audience B, and Audience C.

Deploy Actionable Segments

Easily group donors by behavior, demographics, or giving patterns to send the right message at the right time.

Diagram showing DonorSpring logo connected to two donor segments labeled Donors Segment A and Donors Segment B with lists of donor icons and details.

Unlock Data-Driven Insights

Turn donor data into practical guidance with reporting and analytics that help you improve results and grow impact.

Donation insights dashboard showing a line graph of donations over a week, total donations of $12,890, bar charts of donation amount spread and donations by hour.
Five blue stars in a horizontal row representing a 5-star rating.
“We wanted to connect to a younger audience but could not afford to start an acquisition program. DonorSpring enables us to in a faster and more targeted way with no risk.”
Caroline K.
Director of Development Operations, The Legal Aid Society
Five blue stars in a horizontal row representing a 5-star rating.
"DonorSpring has been a game-changer for 2nd Story's fundraising initiative. Their innovative approach and user-friendly donor platform have not only amplified 2nd Story's mission but also fostered a steadfast community of supporters who wholeheartedly believe in the transformative power of true stories. There's no doubt that DonorSpring is instrumental in driving our growth."
Lauren S.
Managing Director, 2nd Story
Five blue stars in a horizontal row representing a 5-star rating.
"As a non-profit open-air theater located in the Hudson Valley, DonorSpring has not only helped us reach audience members who have dropped from our radar, since our move to our new permanent home, but DS has also helped us to expand our reach to new audiences."
Samir P.
Development Manager, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Project
CLIENT STORIES

Discover How DonorSpring Helps Nonprofits Grow Donations

Real results from organizations growing their donor base, saving time, and achieving greater impact

White arrow pointing diagonally up and to the right on a black background.
Person in a plaid blazer holding a tablet with a donations icon overlay.
WHY DONORSPRING

More Donors.
Less Effort.
No Risk.

FAQs

Lapsed Donor Reactivation FAQ

What are lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Lapsed donors are individuals who have previously donated to your nonprofit but have not made a contribution within a specific timeframe, often one or two years.

Why do donors lapse?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Donors may lapse for various reasons, such as financial changes, lack of engagement, dissatisfaction with communication, or simply forgetting about the organization.

How can nonprofits identify lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Nonprofits can use donor management systems to track giving history and flag donors who haven’t given within a typical timeframe for their segment.

What is the best way to win back lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

The best approach involves personalized outreach, clear communication of your impact, and offering flexible giving options tailored to the donor’s interests.

How long should nonprofits wait before targeting lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

It’s generally recommended to start re-engagement efforts after 6–12 months of inactivity, depending on your donor base and typical giving cycles.

Why is it important to focus on lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Reengaging lapsed donors is often more cost-effective than acquiring new donors, and these individuals have already shown interest in your cause.

What types of campaigns are effective for reactivating lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Successful campaigns include personalized emails, heartfelt letters, impact-focused updates, or exclusive events designed to reconnect with former donors.

What should I say to a lapsed donor?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Start by expressing gratitude for their past support, share the difference their donation made, and invite them to continue their impact.

How do nonprofits measure the success of lapsed donor campaigns?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Key metrics include reactivation rates, donation amounts from reengaged donors, and their retention rates over time.

What are common mistakes nonprofits make with lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Common mistakes include generic outreach, over-solicitation, failing to address why the donor may have lapsed, and not thanking them for their past contributions.

How can data help in re-engaging lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Data allows nonprofits to segment lapsed donors, understand their giving history, and create tailored strategies to meet their preferences.

Should I ask lapsed donors for feedback?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Yes! Asking for feedback can provide insights into why they stopped giving and help improve your donor engagement strategy.

What role does storytelling play in winning back lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Storytelling helps donors see the tangible impact of their support, making them more likely to re-engage emotionally and financially.

Can technology help re-engage lapsed donors?

Blue upward-pointing chevron arrow icon.

Absolutely! Tools like DonorSpring provide analytics, automated campaigns, and personalized messaging to make reactivation easier and more effective